Measurement of pupil destinations could also be strengthened

Schools could be required to ensure pupils are ‘ready-for-work’, as well as being held accountable for what pupils go on to do after they leave school, if the recommendations of the Milburn review are implemented.

The review, carried out by former health secretary Alan Milburn and published this week, makes recommendations across a number of areas of public policy, including health and social security as well as education. Calling for a ‘system reset’, it argues that currently schools are ‘focused on qualifications, with too little accountability for prioritising the work readiness of students’. It proposes introducing a new ‘ready-for-work’ standard which would assess whether individual pupils are ‘work-ready’, then aggregate that data to school level ‘through a ready-for-work rate, including the gaps experienced by young people on Free School Meals and those with SEND’. The new standard would have the same status as other headline accountability measures used by Ofsted. However, it is not clear from the report how schools would be assessed, or the specific criteria that would be used, to determine if the ‘ready-for-work’ standard is being met. The review wants the new standard to be in place by 2028.

The review also calls for destination measures to be strengthened so that a school ‘is judged more clearly by where young people actually go after they leave and whether they remain successfully engaged in education, training or work’. Arguing that schools should be ‘judged fairly for the progress they enable, rather than simply reflecting the advantages or disadvantages of the communities they serve’, it calls for this new outcome measure to take into account things like pupils’ starting points and socio-economic circumstances. The timetable for the measure to be in place is again 2028, but again there is also little detail on precisely how it will measured and assessed.

Commenting on the proposals, Pepe Di’Iasio, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, welcomed aspects of the review but said it was ‘disappointing to see how quickly the report defaults to the usual mishmash of targets, tests, and new accountability measures which are a hallmark of many other reports over recent years. Adding a new ready-for-work standard into school performance measures and Ofsted inspections will create yet more pressure on a system which is already overwhelmed with expectations and which is simply not resourced to deliver a whole new tier of requirements. If the government intends to do this then it must come up with a realistic plan and the funding to enable schools to deliver this expectation’.

Among many other recommendations for schools and colleges, the report says it should be mandatory for both primary and secondary schools to use data to identify and support pupils at risk of becoming NEET (not in education, employment or training). This would build on effective work already taking place in many schools, using RONI (risk of NEET indicator tools) it suggests. The review’s interim report had found that many of the strongest predictors of becoming NEET, including low attainment, absence, exclusions, care experience and special educational needs and disabilities (SEND), are visible well before a young person leaves education.

Commenting on this proposal, Matt Wrack, general secretary of the NASUWT union, said: ‘The proposal to make risk-of-NEET indicators mandatory in both primary and secondary schools raises serious concerns about early labelling. Predictions about a child’s future could affect their confidence, adults’ expectations and the opportunities offered to them. Support should respond to pupils’ needs and changing circumstances based on high expectations for all and a wide range of educational choices’.

Also commenting on the review’s proposals, chief executive of the Education Policy Institute, Julie McCulloch said ‘Better measurement will help, but schools and colleges are only one influence on where young people end up, and accountability must reflect that. Identifying pupils at risk of disengaging while they’re still at school should bring extra support, not lower expectations of what they can achieve’.

The government has said it agrees with the report’s core principles, and will publish a White Paper next year setting out it’s planned response in detail, with legislation to follow. The Department for Education (DfE) has said it will consider the recommendations carefully.