Independent review of complaints being piloted

Ofsted’s chief inspector has vowed to alleviate the ‘unnecessary pressures’ that come with school inspection. Delivering a speech at the Schools and Academies Show in Birmingham this week, Sir Martyn Oliver cited his own experience running a multi academy trust, saying he was aware of the ‘unique pressures’ school leaders face: ‘I know what it is to make decisions like the ones you make every day. To worry about this child’s home life or that child’s absence. To make the most of very limited resources. To set long-term priorities while looking out for your staff every day and maintaining good relationships with parents and carers.’

He said he planned to reduce the ‘undue’ pressure of inspection, and was ‘busy in talks with the Department for Education and the leadership unions about some changes that aim to do that.’ While he couldn’t yet say ‘how that might look’, he promised there would be more detail soon. The news of discussions with unions comes just weeks after the NEU, NAHT and ASCL unions said they had lost confidence in the leadership of Ofsted. Last month the NEU’s Daniel Kebede called on Sir Martyn to resign, while the ASCL passed a formal vote of no confidence in the inspectorate’s leadership. However, a spokesperson for education secretary Lucy Powell subsequently confirmed that Sir Martyn retained her confidence. Much controversy has focused on Ofsted’s report-card style framework, introduced last autumn, with an independent review finding almost nine in ten schools felt the new inspections had a negative impact on staff wellbeing.

Earlier this month Ms Powell told the education select committee that she wanted to ‘see context and inclusion…being recognised in a different way’ during inspections, and Sir Martyn addressed the question of context in his speech. He said he did not want schools ‘to be penalised for working in a more challenging local area or for taking on children who have more complex behaviours and needs’, adding ‘But I do want to know that their needs are being met.’ He stressed that he was aware that some schools were ‘trying to swim against a current, while watching others navigate much calmer waters’, and that Ofsted would always take a ‘broad’ view of a school’s context. He said that inspectors looked at ‘data over time’ and took into account ‘SEND, free school meals, children in need, stability and deprivation levels and so on.’ Sir Martyn also pointed to Ofsted’s use of a ‘similar schools model’, making comparisons between schools operating in similar contexts.

Elsewhere in the speech, Sir Martyn noted that the inspectorate is piloting an independent complaints review service, which will introduce independent external oversight and have the power to advise (though not insist) that an inspection judgement should be reopened. He said that once the pilot concluded he would ‘work with the trade unions to decide what happens next’, pledging ‘No decisions will be made without proper conversations, and I’ll listen very carefully to every piece of feedback.’ The chief inspector rounded off his speech by noting that Ofsted is ‘seeing the ‘expected standard’ grade most often across all our report cards – indicative of all the really great practice out there.’ and concluded: ‘Pushing for ever-higher standards includes pushing ourselves at Ofsted, too. I am committed to improving things for every one of you as professionals as well as for the children we’re all here to serve.’